Taste Test: Best Dairy-Free Ice Cream Brands of 2025

Dairy-free ice cream isn’t just a trend—it’s a lifesaver for people like me who want the joy of dessert without the gut-wrenching aftermath. I’ve had my fair share of trial and error navigating the dairy-free aisle, and over time, I’ve come to prefer these alternatives to traditional ice cream. The texture, flavor, and creativity of today’s brands are changing the game.

In this taste test, I’m sharing my top picks for the best dairy-free ice cream brands of 2025—based on flavor, texture, and how well they satisfy the craving when you need something sweet. Whether you’re lactose intolerant, vegan, or just exploring better-for-you options, these are the scoops worth knowing.

1. So Delicious – Coconut Milk Vanilla Bean

Texture: Smooth and light with creamy coconut notes
Flavor: Clean vanilla bean with a subtle tropical vibe
Base: Coconut milk
Best For: Those who want a familiar, comforting flavor with a dairy-free twist
Score: ★ 8/10

2. Ben & Jerry’s Non-Dairy – P.B. & Cookies

Texture: Creamy with plenty of cookie crunch
Flavor: Rich peanut butter flavor with just enough chocolate cookie to balance
Base: Almond milk
Best For: Anyone who loves texture and bold flavor in every bite
Score: ★ 8.5/10

3. Oatly – Chocolate Fudge

Texture: Thick and indulgent, melts like the real deal
Flavor: Deep chocolate that’s not overly sweet
Base: Oat milk
Best For: Chocoholics who miss classic ice cream texture
Score: ★ 9/10

4. Talenti Sorbetto – Roman Raspberry

Texture: Silky smooth and refreshing
Flavor: Bold raspberry flavor with a natural fruit finish
Base: Fruit-based (no dairy, no cream)
Best For: Fans of fruity, bright desserts that still satisfy
Score: ★ 8/10

5. Halo Top Dairy-Free – Chocolate

Texture: A little lighter than traditional ice cream but still creamy
Flavor: Sweet with a mild chocolate flavor
Base: Coconut milk
Best For: Health-conscious dessert lovers looking for lower-calorie options
Score: ★ 7.5/10

Pro Tip: When shopping for dairy-free ice cream, always check the label—some products use coconut, almond, or soy bases, which may not meet every dietary need. Some also include additives or sweeteners that can affect gut health.

Final Scoop

Living in the South doesn’t mean you have to sacrifice flavor when going dairy-free. Whether you’re shopping at Publix, Walmart, or Kroger, these five brands offer accessible, delicious options for every kind of sweet tooth. With more options hitting shelves each year, it’s easier than ever to find a pint that fits your taste and dietary needs.

According to the Mayo Clinic, many people with lactose intolerance benefit from switching to lactose-free ice cream or vegan frozen desserts. Top pick? Oatly’s Chocolate Fudge wins for both flavor and texture—hands down. Tried one we didn’t include?

Drop your favorite dairy-free ice cream brand in the comments—and if you’re exploring more plant-based favorites, don’t miss my Unlock Gut Health with These Powerful Fermented Snacks. Finding the best dairy-free ice cream doesn’t have to be hard—these scoops prove that flavor and comfort can go hand-in-hand.